In St. Augustine School v. Underly, (7th Cir., Dec. 20, 2021), the U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals sent back to the district court a suit challenging Wisconsin's refusal to provide bus transportation to students at St. Augustine School. The decision was based on a Wisconsin statute that requires school districts to bus private school students, but limits the obligation to only one private school affiliated with the same religious denomination or sponsoring group in each attendance district. Another Catholic school in the same district was already receiving bussing aid. In 2018, the 7th Circuit rejected 1st Amendment challenges to the law and upheld the state's decision. (See prior posting.)
Plaintiffs sought review in the U.S. Supreme Court. In 2020, the Supreme Court granted certiorari, summarily vacated the judgment below and remanded the case to the 7th Circuit in light of its decision in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue. At that point, the 7th Circuit decided to certify to the Wisconsin Supreme Court the state law question of how to determine if two schools are affiliated with the same denomination. The Wisconsin Supreme Court responded to the certified question in July of this year. (See prior posting.) Applying that guidance, the 7th Circuit this week held:
We conclude that the Superintendent’s decision in the case before us was not justified by neutral and secular considerations, but instead necessarily and exclusively rested on a doctrinal determination that both St. Augustine and St. Gabriel’s were part of a single sponsoring group—the Roman Catholic church—because their religious beliefs, practices, or teachings were similar enough....
