Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Court Rejects Proposed Accommodation for Home-School Football Players with Religious Objections to Vaccination

In Krainis v. Howell, (D ME, Nov. 16, 2026), a Maine federal district court refused to issue a preliminary injunction that would allow plaintiffs' home-schooled teen-age children to participate on public high-school athletic teams without complying with Maine's vaccination requirements. Plaintiffs, who have religious objections to vaccinations, claim that Maine's requirements violate their free exercise and equal protection rights. Plaintiffs proposed that the court issue an order allowing their children to participate except when any student on their team or an opposing team is also unvaccinated.

In rejecting plaintiffs' arguments, the court relied in large part on the reasoning in We the Patriots USA, Inc. v. Makin, a similar challenge decided in September by another judge in the District of Maine. (See prior posting.) The court in Krainis, however, also addressed plaintiffs' unique proposal to limit their students' participation to games in which no other student on either team was unvaccinated. The court said in part:

Although the Court appreciates the Plaintiffs’ innovative attempts to mitigate the impact of a favorable order on others, including team members, the Court is not convinced that their suggestions are practical or workable......

Furthermore, because the other school districts are not parties to this litigation, it is unclear whether the Court could compel their cooperation in implementing the proposed injunction....

Under the Plaintiffs’ proposal, B.K.’s and E.K.’s ability to participate in school athletics would depend, in part, on objections raised by parents of vaccinated teammates and information supplied by opposing coaches....  Although the Court would determine the scope and conditions of any preliminary relief, ... the proposal would nevertheless place substantial practical control over the availability of federal injunctive relief in the hands of private individuals.  Assuming that the Court were to conclude that the Plaintiffs are exercising their constitutional religious rights in playing for the WHS teams, it seems odd at best to allow third parties to countermand their exercise of religious rights.  The Court is aware of no other situation where an individual’s exercise of a constitutional right depends upon the acquiescence of others....

Moreover, the Court is not convinced that the Plaintiffs’ proposed conditions sufficiently account for the privacy interests of other students....