Tuesday, November 17, 2026

School Board Violated Church's Rights by Denying It Year-Long Rental of School for Sunday Services

In The Pines Church v. Hermon School Department, (D ME, Nov. 13, 2026), a Maine federal district court issued a declaratory judgment finding that a 5-member school board (known as a School Committee) violated a Christian church's free exercise rights and violated Maine's public accommodations law when it rejected the church's application for a one-year lease of space in Hermon High School to use on Sunday mornings for church services. While the school had entered short-term leases with other organizations for use of school space, this was the first request for a year-long lease. The court said in part:

... I find that at least three of the five decision makers acted under the influence of bad motive and in so doing violated the Plaintiffs’ rights under the First Amendment.  The members “concerns” were threadbare and definitively dispelled by [Superintendent] Grant.  Despite Grant’s urging to reflect upon its lawyer’s legal advice at each successive close call and eventual collision with the First Amendment, the Committee simply reiterated pretextual reasons to reject the Church’s request that were not legitimate in the light of all of the evidence and even if they had been marginally legitimate, the decision was clearly and substantially tainted with anti-Church motives....

For its part, Defendant points to the majority vote in favor of a month-to-month use arrangement as proof of the lack of bias on the part of its committee members.  I agree with the Church that this was not persuasive evidence of a lack of bad motive but to the contrary, is evidence of bad motive.  The Committee knew the Church required a more fixed arrangement before uprooting itself from its then current location than a month-to-month arrangement provides.  This appears to me to have been an offer designed to be rejected not one born of wholesome support for the Free Exercise Clause...

There are certainly facts in this record that toe the line between apprehension toward the Church itself and legitimate concerns about complications that arise with a new type of use for a school.  But novelty is not a basis to discriminate against religious organizations and whatever novelty this situation presented to the Committee was demystified by the sound legal advice its lawyers provided to the Committee before its discussion and decision.....

The court also awarded nominal damages. Maine Wire reports on the decision.