Wednesday, July 13, 2016
Title VII Is Sole Basis For Claims of Religious Discrimination Against Federal Employee
In Holly v. Jewell, (ND CA, July 11, 2016), a California federal magistrate judge held that Title VII is the sole remedy for discrimination in federal employment. Neither the First Amendment nor RFRA may be used as the basis for a religious discrimination claim by a federal employee. In the case, plaintiff who was employed as a maintenance worker at the San Francisco Maritime National Historic Park was also a Baptist minister. While on a break and out of uniform, he performed a baptism at the seashore adjoining the park. He was terminated for this-- though plaintiff also complained that he was questioned about a Bible that he kept to read on breaks. The court dismissed plaintiff's RFRA claim, holding that recent Supreme Court RFRA decisions have not changed the rule that Title VII is the exclusive remedy for discrimination in federal employment. The court also dismissed plaintiff's free exercise claim to the extent that it challenges conduct protected by Title VII, but held that plaintiff can file an amended complaint to the extent that he has a First Amendment claim that is separate from his Title VII claim.