Thursday, September 08, 2022

New York Violates Speech Rights of Adoption Agency By Requiring Placement With Unmarried and Same-Sex Families.

In New Hope Family Services, Inc. v. Poole, (ND NY, Sept. 6, 2022), a New York federal district court issued a permanent injunction prohibiting the state of New York from requiring New Hope, a religiously affiliated social service agency, to provide adoption services to unmarried or same-sex couples. The state Office of Children and Family Services contended that New Hope's policy of referring such clients to other agencies violated its anti-discrimination rules. Citing a previous holding by the Second Circuit, the court concluded that "by compelling it to place children with unmarried and same-sex couples, OCFS is necessarily compelling New Hope to engage in the speech required for that conduct...." While agreeing that the state has a compelling interest in avoiding discrimination and increasing the pool of potential adopting families, the court held that OCFS's rule is not narrowly tailored to advance those interests:

New Hope's "recusal-and-referral" practice was a more narrowly tailored means of avoiding discrimination than the closure of New Hope's adoption operation.