U.S. Catholic Bishops Issue 2013 Report On Clergy Abuse Allegations and Costs

On March 28, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops released its most recent report on the Church's ongoing efforts to deal with clergy sexual abuse of minors.  Its 2013 Annual Report on the Implementation of the “Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People" discloses that in 2013 there were 370 new credible allegations of sexual abuse of a minor made against 290 priests or deacons. Only nine of the allegations involved victims who were under 18 in 2013. The rest involved adults who claim abuse in the past. 80% of the victims were male while 20% were female.  Five of the 370 allegations involved only child pornography. 69% of the allegations involved conduct that occurred or began between 1960 and 1984. During 2013, dioceses and eparchies paid out $108.9 million as follows: $61 million in settlements; $6 million in therapy for victims; $10.4 million in support for offenders; $28.9 million in attorneys' fees; and $2.4 million in other costs. In the past ten years, costs related to claims have totaled $109 million. Insurance covered 21% of the amounts paid out in 2013. The report deals separately with abuse complaints directed to clerical and mixed religious institutes where 2013 saw 94 new credible allegations of abuse. Catholic World News covers the report. [Thanks to Pewsitter.com for the lead.]

U.S. Catholic Diocese Sues Diocese In Ireland Over Transfer of Abusive Priest

AP reported yesterday that an unusual lawsuit has been filed in court in Ireland by the U.S. Catholic diocese of New Ulm, Minnesota. The suit was filed in February against Diocese of Clogher in Ireland and the religious order, Servants of the Paraclete, alleging that in 1981 the Irish diocese transferred a priest, Rev. Francis Xavier Markey, to Minnesota without warning U.S. church officials that he had been accused of sexual abuse. The New Ulm diocese has been sued by a victim of Markey's.

$525M Default Judgment Entered Against Affiliate of Evangelist Tony Alamo

AP reports that an Arkansas trial court yesterday issued a $525 million default judgment against Twenty First Century Holiness Tabernacle Church-- an affiliate of Alamo Ministries.  The judgment came in a suit by 7 women who as young girls were physically, sexually and psychologically abused by evangelist Tony Alamo.  Alamo is presently serving a 175-year prison sentence for taking girls across state lines for sex. (See prior posting.) This week's default judgment gave each victim both actual and punitive damages in amounts totaling between $30 and $87 million per victim. Plaintiffs' attorney plans to register the judgment in California and begin levying on property there to satisfy the judgment.

Missouri Catholic Diocese Settles Two Abuse Lawsuits

Last week, the Catholic Diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph settled two separate state court lawsuits stemming from the child pornography activities of priest Shawn Ratigan.  AP reports that last Friday a court approved a settlement of $1.275 million in a suit brought by parents whose daughter was photographed in nude and semi-nude poses by Ratigan when the girl was 10 to 12 years old. A $525,000 settlement in a second suit was approved last Wednesday in a suit involving a girl who was photographed by Ratigan when the girl was 9 years old. In each of the suits, thejudge also entered a $500,000 default judgment against Ratigan who was sentenced to 50 years in prison last year. In 2012 Bishop Robert Finn was convicted of a misdemeanor for failing to authorities his suspicion of child abuse by Ratigan.  Finn was sentenced to two years probation. (See prior posting.)

India Supreme Court Orders Stop To Imminent Devadasi Ceremony That Often Exploits Young Girls

The Calcutta Telegraph reports that India's Supreme Court yesterday took quick action in response to a recently filed Public Interest Lawsuit to try to prevent exploitation of young girls in a ceremony scheduled for the night of February 13-14 in front of the Uttangi Durga Hindu temple in the city of Davangere in India's Karnataka state. According to the report:

Under the devadasi system, girls on attaining puberty are married off to the local temple’s female deity at a ceremony willingly consented to by the parents in most cases, though in some cases local panchayats have been known to use a certain degree of coercion.

After being “married” off and “dedicated” to the deity, the girls are forced to sing and dance before their village chiefs, rich landlords and other influential persons and have often been sexually exploited.

The PIL cited newspaper reports that said that despite the Karnataka Devadasis (Prohibition of Dedication) Act, 1982, the practice continued.... The petition alleged that many devadasis, exploited by local landlords and influential men, had been left to fend for themselves and were dying of poverty or sexually transmitted diseases.

The court told counsel for the non-profit foundation filing the suit that they should have come to the court sooner.  As an interim measure, the court yesterday faxed an order to the chief secretary of the state of Karnataka ordering him to take steps to prevent unmarried girls from being forced to become devadasis at the February 13-14 religious event.

2 Minnesota Catholic Dioceses Sued In Demand For Files of Abusive Priests

In a suit filed in a Minnesota state trial court on Wednesday against two Catholic dioceses, plaintiff who claims to have been abused as a 13-year old boy by Catholic priest James Vincent Fitzgerald is seeking release by the dioceses of the complete files of priests who have been credibly accused of abuse. As reported by Forum News Service, the alleged victim, identified only as "Doe 30", has sued the Diocese of Duluth and the Diocese of New Ulm saying that the abuse occurred in 1976. This is the third suit by various victims against the Diocese of Duluth demanding release of files.  So far the diocese has only released the names (along with basic biographical data) of accused priests. Fitzgerald worked at 6 parishes of the Diocese of Duluth from 1957 to 1983, and worked in the New Ulm diocese from 1977-78. Plaintiff's attorney claims the Duluth Diocese knew of should have known of Fitzgerald's actions and moved him between parishes where he continued to have access to children. The Diocese however says that no abuse complaints against Fitzgerald surfaced prior to late last year.

Milwaukee Archdiocese Files Reorganization Plan; Criticized As Inadequate By Victims

AP reports that the Catholic Archdiocese of Milwaukee yesterday filed its Plan of Reorganization with federal bankruptcy court. Under the Plan, $4 million will be set aside to compensate 125 clergy sex abuse victims-- the smallest per victim payments yet in any of the 11 bankruptcy reorganizations of dioceses around the country. Over 400 individuals filing claims as victims will not receive payment-- including those beyond the statute of limitations, claimants who already received a settlement from the archdiocese and those abused by priests from religious orders or by parish employees. Also $500,000 will be set aside in a lifetime Therapy Fund for victims.  A Q&A on the Plan of Reorganization posted on the Archdiocese's website gives details on the plan. In a letter posted on the Archdiocese's website, Archbishop Listecki said that the Archdiocese will emerge from bankruptcy with at least $7 million in debt, adding:

The archdiocese has historically operated on a balanced budget, so the burden of paying off this debt will certainly be part of our penance.  I wish we wouldn’t have had to spend the past three years and millions of dollars on attorneys’ fees to get to this point, but now we have a Plan that moves us forward.

Abuse victims strongly criticized the Plan as insufficient, one saying: "It is much like being raped all over again...." The victim advocacy group SNAP issued a statement calling the Plan "breath-taking in its callousness, selfishness and arrogance."

St. Louis Diocese Provides Court With List of Accused Priests and Victims

According to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch yesterday, the Catholic Archdiocese of St. Louis has complied with a trial court's order to turn over to the court and plaintiff's attorney in a pending lawsuit the names of priests who have been accused of sexually abusing minors over a 20-year period, as well as contact information of the victims. The order comes in a suit filed in 2011 by a woman who says she was abused by a now-defrocked priest. Last week the Missouri Supreme Court rejected the Archdiocese's challenge to the trial court's order.  The list remains under seal. The trial court will appoint an attorney to make first contact with the victims, rather than having that contact come from plaintiff's lawyer.

U.N. Committee Report Critical of Vatican on Protection of Children

On January 31, the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child finished its 65th Session after adopting its concluding observations and recommendations on six nations, including the Holy See. (Press release.) As reported yesterday by CNN, the Committee's Concluding Observations on the Second Periodic Report of the Holy See (full text) harshly criticized the Vatican's handling of child sexual abuse within the Church. The 16-page report says in part:

The Committee is particularly concerned that in dealing with allegations of child sexual abuse, the Holy See has consistently placed the preservation of the reputation of the Church and the protection of the perpetrators above children’s best interests, as observed by several national commissions of inquiry....

The Committee is concerned about the situation of children born of Catholic priests, who, in many cases, are not aware of the identity of their fathers. The Committee is also concerned that the mothers may obtain a plan for regular payment from the Church until the child is financially independent only if they sign a confidentiality agreement not to disclose any information....

The Committee is particularly concerned that: ... Due to a code of silence imposed on all members of the clergy under penalty of excommunication, cases of child sexual abuse have hardly ever been reported to the law enforcement authorities....; Reporting to national law enforcement authorities has never been made compulsory..... Church authorities, including at the highest levels of the Holy See have shown reluctance and in some instances, refused to cooperate with judicial authorities and national commissions of inquiry.... Limited efforts have been made to empower children enrolled in Catholic schools and institutions to protect themselves from sexual abuse.

(See prior related posting.)  A Vatican Radio interview with Archbishop Silvano Tomasi, Permanent Observer of the Holy See to the United Nations in Geneva, and a statement from the Vatican react to the report. Both of these reactions include expressions of concern apparently directed to the U.N. report's call for the Vatican to review its position on abortion and identify circumstances under which it can be permitted.

Montana Catholic Diocese Files For Chapter 11 Protection To Implement $17.5M Settlement of Abuse Cases

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Helena, Montana filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization on Friday, according to NBC News. The filing comes in anticipation of a $15 million settlement for 362 victims of clergy abuse who have sued claiming that the diocese knew or should have known of the abuse that took place from the 1940's to the 1980's. Another $2.5 million will be set aside for victims who have not yet come forward. Most of the settlement will be funded by insurance carriers, but the diocese will pay at least $2.5 million additionally. The diocese covers 21 counties and parts of two others in western and north central Montana.

Sexual Abuse Suit Against Yehshiva University Dismissed On Statute of Limitations Grounds

In Twersky v. Yeshiva University, (SD NY, Jan. 30, 2014), a New York federal district court dismissed on statute of limitations grounds a suit by 34 former students at Yeshiva University High School for Boys claiming that between 1968 and 1992 they were abused variously by an administrator who eventually became the school principal, by a Judaic studies teacher employed by the Jewish high school, and by an outside party who was given access to the school dormitory. The suit was brought against the high school, Yeshiva University, former University administrators and trustees alleging fraud, negligence, violation of the NY General Business Law, and of Title IX of the federal Education Amendments Act of 1972. The court rejected claims that the statutes of limitation involved were extended by the federal or state law rules on discovery of wrongdoing, or by the state law doctrine of equitable estoppel.  The Forward reports on the decision.

8th Circuit: Insurance Company Need Not Pay Archdiocese's Settlement In Wrongful Death Suit

In Chicago Insurance Company v. Archdiocese of St. Louis, (8th Cir., Jan. 29, 2014), the U.S. 8th Circuit Court of Appeals held that Chicago Insurance Co. is not required to reimburse the Catholic Archdiocese of St. Louis for amounts the Archdiocese paid to settle a wrongful death claim by the parent of a clergy sex abuse victim who committed suicide. The court held that the Archdiocese failed to show that the settlement was in reasonable anticipation of liability for negligence because the Missouri Supreme Court has held that negligence-based actions against a religious organization that require the court to evaluate the reasonableness of religious doctrine, policy and administration are barred by the 1st Amendment. (And the insurance policy does not cover intentional conduct.) The 8th Circuit held:

we are aware of no authority, and the Archdiocese cites none, that allows a settling insured to recover under an indemnity policy where governing law does not permit the claimant's underlying cause of action against the insured.

Business Insurance reports on the decision.

Chicago Archdiocese Settles Sex Abuse Case For $3.2M

The Chicago Sun-Times reported yesterday that the Catholic Archdiocese of Chicago has reached a settlement of nearly $3.2 million with the victim of sex abuse by former priest Daniel McCormack. The suit charges that the archdiocese and Cardinal Francis George failed to remove McCormack from contact with children even though they knew that he had sexually abused minors.

Court Dismisses Challenge To Exclusion of Private Schools From NY Law Protecting Students From Sex Abuse

In Levi v. New York State Assembly, (SD NY, Jan. 29, 2014), a New York federal district court dismissed on sovereign immunity and legislative immunity grounds a suit challenging the legislature's failure to include private schools (including religious schools) in the coverage of a 2001 state law designed to protect school students from sexual abuse by school employees. Plaintiff, whose daughter attends a Modern Orthodox Jewish school, complains that private schools were omitted because of opposition to their coverage by ultra-Orthodox Jews. He contended that the legislature's action violated the 1st and 14th Amendments.

Litigation Resumes Over Insurance Coverage In Milwaukee Archdiocese Bankruptcy

As the Catholic Archdiocese of Milwaukee completes work on its plan of bankruptcy reorganization, litigation over insurance coverage resumes with competing court filings.  The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reports that the Archdiocese filed suit yesterday in federal bankruptcy court seeking to recover reimbursement from OneBeacon Insurance Co. for over $2.6 million in legal fees incurred defending claims that the Archdiocese allowed priests who were known sexual abusers to have access to children. In litigation begun before the Archdiocese filed for bankruptcy, two state lower courts had ruled that the claims against the Archdiocese fell under the policy exclusion for intentional acts. The Archdiocese appealed those rulings to the Wisconsin Supreme Court, but before that court could decide the appeal the bankruptcy petition was filed and an automatic stay on litigation was triggered. Yesterday, OneBeacon Insurance Co. filed a motion asking the bankruptcy court to lift the automatic stay and allow the state Supreme Court to decide the matter.

Jury Awards $12.5 M Damages Against Florida Baptist Convention In Sex Abuse Case

Baptist Press (Jan. 21) reports that last week, after a 6-day trial on damages, a Lake County, Florida jury awarded damages of $12.5 million against the Florida Baptist Convention to a man who was molested by a former church planting pastor.  In 2005, Douglas Myers, pastor of Triangle Community Church in Eustis, Florida sexually abused 13-year old Christopher Edwards. Myers has completed a 7-year prison sentence for that offense, and has subsequently been sentenced by Maryland courts for other earlier custodial child abuse offenses.  The attorney for Florida Baptist Convention says he is confident that the civil jury verdict will be overturned on appeal because the pastor was never an employee of the Florida Baptist Convention.

Vatican Reports To U.N. Committee on Priest Abuse; Releases New Data On Priests Defrocked

On Thursday, Archbishop Silvano Tomasi, the Vatican's Permanent Observer to the United Nations in Geneva, made a presentation (full text) to the U.N. Committee on the Convention of the Rights of the Child. AP reports:

the Holy See was interrogated for eight hours about the scale of [clergy sex] abuse and what it was doing to prevent it.

Vatican Radio, on Thursday interviewed  Bishop Charles Scicluna about the U.N. hearing. Scicluna described the hearing as "grueling," but said:

I think that we put out in a very clear, coherent way to the international community that the Holy See “gets it”....

Meanwhile, AP reported yesterday that in an annual report just released, the Vatican says that Pope Benedict XVI defrocked 260 priests in 2011 and 124 in 2012 in the Church's reaction to clergy sex abuse. Responding yesterday to the newly disclosed numbers, SNAP (Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests) issued a press release criticizing the Vatican, saying: "The Vatican's focus should be on prevention, not on damage control on the tail end after a priest, nun, seminarian, brother or bishop has already assaulted dozens of boys or girls."Abuse

Spokane Diocese Suing Its Bankruptcy Lawyers For Malpractice

AP reported on Wednesday that the Catholic Diocese of Spokane has refiled in federal bankruptcy court its bankruptcy malpractice lawsuit against the law firm of Paine Hamblin and two lawyers who were members of the firm. The firm handled the reorganization of the diocese that began with bankruptcy filings in 2004 and ended in 2007 after a $48 million settlement with 175 abuse victims. (See prior posting.)  The malpractice suit seeking return of millions of dollars in legal fees and more millions of dollars in damages was originally filed in 2012, but dismissed on technical grounds. The 2012 suit was described by the Spokane Spokesman-Review:

The diocese... says ... that bankruptcy lawyers Shaun Cross and Greg Arpin failed to explore other means of ending the abuse scandal ... [and] blames the lawyers for writing a bankruptcy plan that failed to assess and adequately fund the risk of new claims, which nearly forced the foreclosure of churches. The lawsuit also accuses the attorneys of a conflict of interest, in shielding former Bishop William Skylstad from testifying in the first civil trial alleging sex abuse by filing for bankruptcy on the eve of that suit.

The law firm says it provided excellent representation in guiding the diocese out of a crisis that included over 180 clergy sex abuse claims.

Chicago Archdiocese Releases Files on 30 Priests In Settlement of Abuse Lawsuits

AP reports that yesterday the Catholic Archdiocese of Chicago released 6000 pages of documents relating to 30 priests who have had substantiated sex abuse allegations lodged against them. The step comes as part of the settlement of suits by victims.  Lawyers for the victims say they plan to make the released files public next week.  Files on another 35 priests who have had substantiated abuse complaints against them have not been released because they were not the subject of the lawsuits that were settled.  The Archdiocese plans to develop a process for release of these additional documents. The Archdiocese yesterday posted a statement about the document release on its website.

UPDATE: The law firm of Jeff Anderson & Associates has now posted the released documents here.

Vatican Says Its Former Nuncio to Dominican Republic Has Diplomatic Immunity and Is Not Extraditable On Sex Abuse Charges

The Vatican says that Polish Catholic Archbishop Josef Wesolowski who is being investigated on sex abuse charges by authorities in both the Dominican Republic and Poland has full diplomatic immunity.  AP reports today that Wesolowski, who served as Apostolic Nuncio (Ambassador) to the Dominican Republic from 2008 until 2013, was recalled to the Vatican and relieved of his position in August after Pope Francis was informed of rumors that Wesolowski sexually abused teenage boys in the Dominican Republic. Polish prosecutors recently inquired of the Vatican about Wesolowski's legal status as part of the investigation that they are also conducting, and were told that, in addition to diplomatic immunity, Wesolowski is a citizen of the Vatican City state and that the Vatican does not extradite its citizens. The Vatican says it is cooperating with Poland and the Dominican Republic in their investigations, and that two separate Vatican tribunals are investigating Wesolowski for both canonical and criminal violations.