The Greenwich (CT) Times yesterday reported that a candidate in next year's Democratic primary for U.S. Senate, Lee Whitnun, has filed suit in federal district court seeking a declaratory judgment that Greenwich, Connecticut acted unconstitutionally when it permitted the Jewish Federation of Greenwich to use the city's town hall on a Sunday last May for a celebration of Israel's Independence Day. Along with the Independence Day celebration, a Bar Mitzvah ceremony for a visiting exchange student from Israel was held at town hall. The student missed having the ceremony at the usual age of 13 because of the death of his father.
The complaint (full text) in Whitnum v. Town of Greenwich, (D CT, filed 9.8/2011), alleges that the arrangement violates the Establishment Clause as well as the "no preference" clause of the Connecticut constitution (Art. Seventh). The complaint alleges that the Independence Day celebration resulted in inextricably entangling traditional town hall paraphernalia with religious symbols such as the Star of David and "many displays actively promoting an explicitly religiously Jewish and politically Zionist world view." It contends that "to any reasonable observer, the Greenwich Town Hall functioned as an arm of the local synagogue."
The Executive Director of the UJA Federation of Greenwich defended the event saying: "The Israel celebration has been taking place at Town Hall for decades. I believe that other groups celebrate other national independence days. The celebration of Israeli Independence Day is not a religious event." The Jewish Federation paid a $351 custodial fee for use of the building for the event.
