Saturday, August 29, 2020

RFRA Claim For Insisting On Social Security Number In Passport Application Moves Ahead

 In Carmichael v. Pompeo, (D DC, Aug. 28, 2020), three individuals sued the State Department because it insisted that they furnish their Social Security numbers in order to renew their passports. Plaintiffs claim that identifying themselves with Social Security numbers violates their Christian beliefs. The court dismissed most of plaintiffs' claims, but allowed them to move forward, among others, with their claim under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The court concluded that plaintiffs had adequately alleged a substantial burden on their religious exercise:

They must choose between adhering to their religious beliefs—the sincerity of which is not challenged by the Government nor questioned by the Court—and receiving a government benefit.