The U.S. Supreme Court yesterday, by a vote of 6-3, in John Does 1-3 v. Mills, (Sup. Ct., Oct. 29, 2021), refused to enjoin enforcement of Maine's COVID vaccine mandate while a petition for Supreme Court review of the 1st Circuit's decision is pending. Healthcare workers sued objecting to the absence of religious exemptions from the mandate. The 1st Circuit in an Oct. 19 opinion (full text) refused a preliminary injunction against enforcement. The Supreme Court's Order was issued without an accompanying majority opinion. However, Justice Barrett, joined by Justice Kavanaugh, issued a short concurring opinion which appears to recognize the concern with the Court's increasing use of its "shadow docket" to render important decision. Justice Barrett wrote in part:
When this Court is asked to grant extraordinary relief, it considers, among other things, whether the applicant “‘is likely to succeed on the merits.’” ... I understand this factor to encompass not only an assessment of the underlying merits but also a discretionary judgment about whether the Court should grant review in the case.... Were the standard otherwise, applicants could use the emergency docket to force the Court to give a merits preview in cases that it would be unlikely to take—and to do so on a short fuse without benefit of full briefing and oral argument....
Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justices Thomas and Alito, filed an opinion dissenting from the denial of injunctive relief, saying in part:
Maine has so far failed to present any evidence that granting religious exemptions to the applicants would threaten its stated public health interests any more than its medical exemption already does.
This case presents an important constitutional question, a serious error, and an irreparable injury.... [H]ealthcare workers who have served on the front line of a pandemic for the last 18 months are now being fired and their practices shuttered. All for adhering to their constitutionally protected religious beliefs. Their plight is worthy of our attention.
SCOTUS blog reports on the decision.
