Sunday, August 14, 2022

Idaho Supreme Court Refuses To Stop Effectiveness Of Abortion Bans

In Planned Parenthood Great Northwest v. State of Idaho,(ID Sup. Ct., Aug. 12, 2022), the Idaho Supreme Court, in a 3-2 decision, refused to issue a preliminary injunction to prevent enforcement while litigation is pending of a statute triggered by the overruling of Roe v. Wade imposing a near-total abortion ban, as well as of a six-week abortion ban. The court also vacated a preliminary stay it had previously issued barring enforcement of a law that creates civil liability in suits against persons performing abortions after a fetal heartbeat is detectable. Plaintiffs contend that the statutes violate various provisions of the Idaho constitution. The majority concluded that petitioners had not shown a substantial likelihood of success or violation of a clear legal right as to either of the statutes.

Justice Stegner, joined by Justice Zahn, dissented contending that it is sufficient that petitioners showed irreparable harm if a stay in not granted; they do not need to also show a likelihood of success. The dissent said in part:

The State and the Legislature’s only argument that irreparable harm will not result is that the Idaho Constitution does not protect the right to an abortion. This argument fails because it is premised on a decision we have not yet made.

Fox News reports on the decision.