Wednesday, November 18, 2026

En Banc Review Denied in Challenge to NY's Elimination of Religious Exemptions from School Vaccination Requirement

In Miller v. McDonald, (2d Cir., Nov. 17, 2026), the U.S. 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals by an 9-3 vote denied en banc review of a 3-judge panel's earlier decision that New York's repeal of its religious belief exemption from required school immunizations, while keeping medical exemptions, does not violate either Amish parents' free exercise rights or their parental rights to control their children's religious upbringing.

Judge Park, joined by Judges Bianco and Menashi filed an opinion dissenting from the denial of review, saying in part:

Laws that “substantially interfere with the religious development of the parents’ children” or “pose a very real threat of undermining the religious beliefs and practices that the parents wish to instill in their children” are subject to strict scrutiny....  PHL 2164 does that because it forces Amish parents to choose between giving their children vaccinations that their faith forbids or providing the education that their faith requires.  To impose a burden like that, New York must show that the law is narrowly tailored to achieve a compelling government interest.  

The panel erred by limiting Mahmoud to cases of “ideological indoctrination” and misapplying the state’s interest in “health-and-safety” conditions....

Judge Menashi, joined by Judges Bianco and Park, filed an opinion dissenting from the denial of review, saying in part:

I write separately to note that, even if the panel were correct that Mahmoud and Yoder do not apply in this case, strict scrutiny would still be required because § 2164 is not generally applicable....

The fact that the state allows medically unvaccinated children to attend school shows that it is willing to accommodate students who are unvaccinated for secular reasons that the state favors.... Even if the government could establish that it is able to accommodate only a limited number of unvaccinated students, that would not justify allocating all the accommodations to secular objectors and none to religious objectors.