Showing posts with label ADA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ADA. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 30, 2026

Employer's Religious Refusal to Cover Gender Dysphoria in Its Health Plan May Violate Title VII, But Not ADA

In Bernier v. Turbocam, Inc., (D NH, Sept. 28, 2026), Lillian Bernier, a transgender woman, sued her employer because the company refused to provide coverage in its health plan for gender-affirming care. The president of the company and his wife are evangelical Christians who operates the company according to their religious tradition. That includes a belief that a person's sex is ordained by God and that it should not be obscured through medical treatment. The court dismissed plaintiff's claim of disability discrimination under the Americans with Disabilities Act because the Act excludes from its definition of "disability" gender identity disorders not resulting from physical impairments. However, the court refused to dismiss plaintiff's Title VII sex discrimination claim, saying in part:

Bernier argues that Turbocam adopted the exclusion (and decided not to modify it for her) because of Turbocam’s discriminatory, sex-based animus....

The record here is sufficient for a jury to find that Bernier’s sex is a but-for cause of Turbocam’s refusal to cover the care she seeks. Turbocam states that it adopted the exclusion, declined to modify it, and refused to grant Bernier an exception from it based on Turbocam’s moral disapproval of Bernier’s effort to obscure or change her sex. Further, there is evidence from which a jury could find that Turbocam’s owner harbored personal animus toward Bernier because of her transgender status....

Turbocam contends that, even if a reasonable jury could find that Bernier carried her burden of showing a Title VII violation, Turbocam is nevertheless entitled to summary judgment on Bernier’s Title VII claim because a jury would find in Turbocam’s favor on its RFRA defense.. Bernier responds that RFRA is inapplicable to lawsuits between private parties. The court agrees with Bernier, as do most of the Courts of Appeals to have considered the issue...

Because Bernier sued only after the United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued her a right-to-sue letter, Turbocam contends that the EEOC has effectively delegated governmental enforcement authority to Bernier such that she is for all intents and purposes the “government” under RFRA.... The court is not persuaded. As a matter of law, the EEOC’s “[m]ere approval” of Bernier’s right to initiate a lawsuit does not convert Bernier into a state actor.....

Turbocam asserts that, even if it may not raise RFRA as a defense to Bernier’s Title VII claim, it may raise a defense under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment. Turbocam cites no case in which a court has permitted an employer (other than a church or religious institution) to raise the Free Exercise Clause as a defense in an employment discrimination suit brought by a private plaintiff.  Even assuming such a defense is available in this case, Turbocam agrees that it is subject to the test articulated by the Supreme Court in Smith.  

Smith held “that the right of free exercise does not relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with a ‘valid and neutral law of general applicability.’” 

...Title VII is a neutral law of general applicability. 

While Bernier claims that Turbocam admits it has denied coverage to her because Turbocam opposes gender-affirming care, a reasonable jury could conclude that this does not reflect an intent to discriminate against Bernier because she is transgender.... Moreover, while there is evidence of transgender-based animus in the record, it is also undisputed that Turbocam accommodated Bernier’s name change and addressed another employee’s harassment to Bernier’s satisfaction. Construing the evidence in the light most favorable to the nonmovant, a reasonable jury could find for Turbocam on Bernier’s Title VII claim....

Thursday, February 06, 2025

University Did Not Violate Constitution by Permitting Anti-Zionist Encampment

In Groveman v. Regents of the University of California, (ED CA, Feb. 4, 2025), a California federal district court dismissed a suit alleging that the University of California Davis participated in the denial of plaintiff's constitutional rights when it allowed a pro-Palestinian encampment to continue even though it violated University rules on camping and obtaining permits. Plaintiff who is Jewish and identifies as a Zionist was blocked by the encampment from walking through the campus. He was told that Zionists are not welcome and was struck by an umbrella. Rejecting plaintiff's equal protection claim, the court said in part:

Plaintiff’s allegations fall short of establishing even a causal connection between defendants’ actions and plaintiff’s exclusion from the encampment, let alone that defendants acted with discriminatory intent.... Nor does plaintiff allege any facts suggesting that the university treated Jewish individuals differently than the encampment participants; there is no indication that Jewish individuals sought to establish an encampment, or that if they had, the university would have rebuffed them or prevented them from engaging in comparable treatment of pro-Palestinian protestors....

Rejecting plaintiff's free exercise claim, the court said in part:

Plaintiff alleges that defendants “deprived [him] of the right to express his Jewish identity freely” by “allowing the encampment to thwart religious dialog[ue]” in violation of the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment....  It is not possible to draw a plausible inference that defendants’ actions (or inactions) had the effect of favoring or disfavoring any religion or burdening plaintiff’s religious exercise....

The court also concluded that defendants had qualified immunity. Plaintiff's claim under Title VI was dismissed for lack of standing because he was not connected with any University program that received federal funding. Finally, the court rejected plaintiff's Americans With Disabilities Act claim. While plaintiff had a mobility issue, the fact "that a single path preferred by plaintiff was not accessible does not plead a violation of Title II of the ADA."

Tuesday, November 15, 2022

EEOC Commissioner, In Unusual Procedure, Targets Abortion Travel Benefits By Employers

 Bloomberg Law reported yesterday:

Republican EEOC Commissioner Andrea Lucas is deploying a rarely used agency procedure to silently initiate targeted discrimination probes against at least three companies providing their employees with abortion travel benefits....

The investigations triggered by Commissioner Charges are based on claims by Lucas that by favoring employees seeking abortions and not furnishing comparable benefits to pregnant workers or disabled workers, employers are violating the pregnancy discrimination ban in Title VII or the Americans with Disabilities Act. Bloomberg Law also reports that the EEOC's former general counsel, even though she no longer held a position with the agency after being fired by the Biden administration, last month sent letters to a number of employers warning them of the possibility of such actions by the EEOC.