In Bongo Productions, LLC v. Lawrence, (MD TN, July 9, 2021), a Tennessee federal district court issued a preliminary injunction against enforcement of a recent Tennessee statute that requires businesses which allow individuals to use rest rooms consistent with their gender identity to post a sign by each rest room stating: "This facility maintains a policy of allowing the use of restrooms by either biological sex, regardless of the designation of the restroom." The court concluded that the statute violates plaintiffs' First Amendment free speech rights by compelling speech. The court said in part:
[T]here is simply no basis whatsoever for concluding that the Act is narrowly tailored to serve any compelling governmental purpose....
The defendants are right that, as the Supreme Court has held, strict scrutiny typically does not apply to laws compelling commercial actors to disclose “purely factual and uncontroversial information about the terms under which [their] services will be available.”...
The Supreme Court has expressly recognized that “sexual orientation and gender identity” are, generally speaking, “controversial subjects.”...
[P]eople on one side of a disagreement do not get to unilaterally declare their position to be uncontroversial, because that is not how the concept of “controversy” works. Put another way, the defendants might be wise to accept that, once you are in a heated argument with multiple folks about whether your position is uncontroversial, there is a good chance that you may have already lost.
Gay City News reports on the decision.
