In CBM Ministries of South Central Pennsylvania, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, (PA Commonwlth.. Ct., Dec. 18, 2023), the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court in a 5-2 decision held that privately owned vehicles used by a Bible ministry to transport children from public schools to off-site locations for religious instruction during the school day in released-time programs are not subject to state standards for school buses. CBM operates 87 released-time programs in 8 Pennsylvania counties. It contended that requiring it to comply with the heightened standards for school buses would burden its religious exercise in violation of the Pennsylvania Religious Freedom Protection Act (RFPA). The majority concluded:
While CBM does transport children to and from public schools for the released time program, DOT’s regulations, by their plain language, do not apply to vehicles that are neither owned by nor contracted with a school. In other words, the text of the enabling statute expressly limits the reach of DOT’s regulatory power in this area.
President Judge Jubelirer, joined by Judge Wojcik dissented, saying in part:
I fear the Majority’s overly narrow reading of the enabling statute thwarts the legislature’s intent, pursuant to its police power, to empower PennDOT to keep children safe when they are being transported to and from public school during the school day.
The dissenters rejected plaintiff's religious freedom argument saying that Vehicle Code provisions that protect the public from unsafe operation of motor vehicles are explicitly excluded from coverage under the RFPA, and that "for a given regulation to violate RFPA, it must 'substantially den[y an organization] a reasonable opportunity to engage in activities . . . fundamental to its religion.'"
