Top 10 Religious Liberty and Church-State Developments of 2024

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year.  My choices are based on the importance of the pick to law or policy, regardless of whether the development has garnered significant media attention. With each pick, I link to one or a few of numerous postings on the topic. The selection of top stories obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment. Indeed, as religion, culture and politics increasingly overlap, there are even questions about whether certain developments should be seen as "religion" stories at all. I welcome e-mail comment at religionclause@gmail.com on my choices. Here are my Top Ten picks:

1. Title VI investigations by the Department of Education and Title VI lawsuits by Jewish students proliferate as the continuing Gaza war triggers antisemitic and anti-Zionist demonstrations on campuses across the country.

2. States increasingly ban gender-affirming care for minors.

3. Voters in 7 states approve abortion rights ballot measures; proposals lose in 3 states.

4. Religion in public schools roars back as an issue: Bibles in the classroom, school chaplains, 10 Commandments in classrooms, released time programs.

5. Supreme Court punts on two sensitive issues: FDA approval of abortion pills (lack of standing), and whether federal law on emergency room care pre-empts state abortion bans (cert. improvidently granted).

6. Mixed  results in suits by teachers who claim religious right to refuse to call students by their preferred pronouns as courts enjoin Title IX rules that protect transgender students from discrimination in schools.

7. Oklahoma Supreme Court says religious charter school is unconstitutional.

8. Indiana appellate courts say state's Religious Freedom law is violated when women are prohibited by from obtaining an abortion that their religious beliefs direct them to obtain.

9. Alabama Supreme Court says wrongful death statute covers destruction of frozen embryos. Legislature quickly reverses that result.

10.  Dozens of cases brought by employees who were denied religious exemptions to Covid vaccine mandate continue to work their way through the courts with mixed results.

Top 10 Church-State and Religious Liberty Developments of 2023

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year.  My choices are based on the importance of the pick to law or policy, regardless of whether the development has garnered significant media attention. With each pick, I link to one of numerous postings on the topic. The selection of top stories obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment. Here is a somewhat different list of top stories and newsmakers from the Religion News Association, the professional association of religion journalists. I welcome e-mail comment at religionclause@gmail.com on my choices. Here are my Top Ten picks:

1. Antisemitism spikes in U.S. as President releases National Strategy to Combat Antisemitism.

2. Supreme Court in 303 Creative v. Elenis says free speech protection allows website designer to refuse to create sites for same-sex weddings in violation of her religious beliefs.

3. State legislatures restrict gender dysphoria treatment for minors and transgender women's participation in competitive sports, while teachers sue over school policies requiring them to use students' preferred pronouns or conceal students' social transitions from parents.

4. Court challenges to state abortion bans continue. Plaintiffs claim bans violate state constitutions or violate their religious beliefs regarding abortion.

5. Supreme Court grants review of FDA rules that permit mail distribution of abortion pill.

6. Suits over past denials of religious exemptions from COVID vaccine mandates continue to play out in the courts.

7. Federal agencies say Title VI prohibits certain forms of antisemitic, Islamophobic, and related forms of discrimination in federally funded programs and activities, even though Title VI does not specifically ban religious discrimination.

8. California's targeting of caste discrimination challenged by Hindu Americans.

9. Oklahoma approves state-funded online Catholic charter school. State AG sues.

10. 9th Circuit allows fraud claim against LDS Church over representations about use of tithed funds to proceed.  Plaintiff is prominent former member who had tithed over $2.6 million.

Top 10 Religious Liberty and Church-State Developments of 2022

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year.  My choices are based on the importance of the pick to law or policy, regardless of whether the development has garnered significant media attention. The selection of top stories obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment. Here is a somewhat different list of top stories and newsmakers from the Religion News Association, the professional association of religion journalists. I welcome e-mail comment at religionclause@gmail.com on my choices. Here are my Top Ten picks:

1. In the Dobbs decision, the Supreme Court overrules Roe v. Wade after premature leak of Court's opinion. Newly imposed abortion restrictions are challenged on Free Exercise grounds by clergy and religious organizations with pro-choice beliefs. Some states act to ensure abortion rights.

2. In Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, Supreme Court repudiates the Lemon test for Establishment Clause violations.

3. In Carson v. Makin, Supreme Court says exclusion of sectarian schools from tuition reimbursement program violates Free Exercise clause.

4. Antisemitic incidents in the U.S. increase. White House creates inter-agency group to counter antisemitism.

5. Numerous lawsuits seek religious exemptions from COVID vaccine mandates. Congress in National Defense Authorization Act orders military to rescind its mandate.

6. Congress enacts Respect for Marriage Act, codifying recognition of same-sex and interracial marriages.

7. Accommodation of transgender students and treatment of minors with gender dysphoria remain highly charged political and legal issues.

8. Battles continue over whether anti-discrimination provisions of Title IX, the Affordable Care Act, and some state laws cover discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity, and scope of exemptions from those provisions for religious institutions.

9. In Ramirez v. Collier, Supreme Court recognizes rights of pastor to lay hands on the prisoner and audibly pray with him during his execution.

10. In Shurtleff v. City of Boston, Supreme Court holds that group's free speech rights were violated by refusing to allow it to briefly fly its Christian flag from City Hall flagpole which is open to other groups for their ceremonies.

Top 10 Religious Liberty and Church-State Developments Of 2021

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year.  My choices are based on the importance of the pick to law or policy, regardless of whether the development has garnered significant media attention. The selection of top stories obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment.  This year many developments were interrelated, so deciding what counts as a separate development was a challenge.  I welcome e-mail comment from those who disagree with my selection of top stories.  Here are my Top Ten picks:

1. A flood of court decisions on religious freedom challenges to COVID-19 restrictions on worship services, followed by state measures to prevent future governmental closing down of church services

2. Supreme Court refuses to enjoin Texas heartbeat abortion law pending appeal, while allowing challenges to the unique law to proceed in lower courts.

3. Extensive challenges to the absence of religious exemptions in COVID vaccine mandates.

4. Supreme Court's increased use of its "shadow docket" to render important decisions.

5. Biden Administration reasserts bans on discrimination against transgender and gay individuals, while treatment of transgender individuals in athletic competitions and in classrooms by teachers who refuse to recognize their gender identity become important issues

6. Supreme Court in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia holds unanimously that Philadelphia has violated the free exercise rights of Catholic Social Services by refusing to contract it to provide foster care services unless it agrees to certify same-sex couples as foster parents. 

7. Congress and President take action against China over Uyghur genocide.

8. The United States returns as a member of the United Nations Human Rights Council.

9. Supreme Court rules on rights of chaplains to be in execution chambers.

10. U.S. bishops back down on denial of communion to President Biden over his views on abortion after Pope supports Biden.

Top 10 Religious Liberty and Church State Developments of 2020

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year-- including developments internationally in the mix.  My choices are based on the importance of the pick to law or policy, regardless of whether the development has garnered significant media attention. The selection of top stories obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment, and I welcome e-mail comment from those who disagree with my choices.  So here are my Top Ten picks-- as one of the most unusual years we have all experienced comes to an end:

(1) Challenges by houses of worship and religious schools to the  limits imposed on them by COVID-19 health orders dominated much of the year. Numerous state and federal courts, including the Supreme Court were called upon to balance free exercise rights against the life and health of community members.

(2) The death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and confirmation of Justice Amy Coney Barrett to take her seat on the Supreme Court promised to continue the Court's movement toward expanded free exercise rights.

(3) The U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Bostock v. Clayton County, Georgia held that the provision of Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act which prohibits discrimination in employment "because of sex" protects gay, lesbian and transgender individuals.

(4) The Supreme Court in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue, held that Montana's exclusion of religious schools from its scholarship tax credit program violates the Free Exercise clause of the U.S. Constitution.

(5)  In June Medical Services L.L.C. v. Russo, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down Louisiana's law that requires doctors at abortion clinics to hold active admitting privileges at a hospital within 30 miles of the clinic.

(6) The Court of Justice of the European Court upheld a law enacted in Belgium's Flemish region that effectively bans Halal and Kosher Slaughter.

(7) The U.S. Supreme Court in Tanzin v. Tanvir held that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act permits suits for damages against federal officials in their individual capacities.

(8) The Department of Health and Human Services adopted a final rule that rolled back health care anti-discrimination coverage in federally supported services. The prior rules protected transgender individuals and those who had accessed abortion services.

(9) In Our Lady of Guadalupe School v. Morrissey-Berru, the U.S. Supreme Court held that two elementary school teachers in separate Catholic schools are covered by the "ministerial exception" so that they cannot sue for employment discrimination.

(10) The U.S. Supreme Court in Little Sisters of the Poor Saints Peter and Paul Home v. Pennsylvania rejected challenges to the Trump Administration's expanded conscience exemptions from the Affordable Care Act's contraceptive coverage mandate.

Top 10 Religious Liberty and Church State Developments of 2019

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year-- including developments internationally in the mix.  My choices are based on the importance of the pick to law or policy, regardless of whether the development has garnered significant media attention. This year has been a particularly active one, and 2020 promises to be even more eventful.  The selection of top stories obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment, and I welcome e-mail comment from those who disagree with my choices.  So here are my Top Ten picks as another year comes to an end:

1. The ongoing battle over abortion rights, including the Supreme Court's action on Indiana's abortion law in Box v. Planned Parenthood, and Justice Thomas opinion focusing on abortion as eugenics; Supreme Court's granting of certiorari on Louisiana's abortion law; increasingly restrictive enactments by various states; and challenges to new HHS health care conscience rules.
   
2. Supreme Court's decision in American Legion v. American Humanist Society clarifying when religious-themed monuments on public property may remain.
   
3. Controversies over transgender rights, including Supreme Court's grant of review in cases on Title VII protections for LGBT employees, and DOD's amended policy on transgender service in the military.
   
4. Growth of anti-Semitism and governmental efforts to combat it, including controversial interpretation of Title VI.
   
5. Litigation and rule-making over whether adoption and foster care agencies receiving government funding can refuse to place children with same-sex couples.
   
6. Elimination of religious exemptions to vaccination requirements in wake of measles outbreaks, especially in New York.
   
7.  Supreme Court weighs in on inmates' access to chaplains during execution.
   
8. Extensions of statutes of limitations lead to flood of clergy abuse cases.
   
9. 7th Circuit upholds tax code's parsonage allowance.
   
10. India's courts and Parliament make major rulings that infringe on religious autonomy: Hindu Marriage Act covers transgender marriage; Parliament outlaws triple talaq; court bans animal sacrifice; power of ecclesiastical courts reduced; disputed holy site awarded to Hindus.

For other opinions on 2019's top stories, see the lists from Don Byrd at BJC, and from from the Religion News Association.

Top Ten 2018 Religious Liberty / Church-State Developments

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year-- including developments internationally in the mix.  My choices are based on the importance of the pick to law or policy, regardless of whether the development has garnered significant media attention..  The selection obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment, and I welcome e-mail comment from those who disagree with my choices.  So here are my Top Ten picks as another rather chaotic year comes to an end:

1. The U.S. Supreme Court issues a narrow decision in the Masterpiece Cakeshop case, failing to resolve the basic question of how to balance religious liberty and free speech rights against demands for equality.
2. Battles continue in the courts over whether existing protections against sex discrimination cover discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity.
3. The third version of President Trump's "travel ban" is upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court.
4. Release of the Pennsylvania Grand Jury report on sexual abuse by Catholic priests in 6 dioceses refocuses attention on the clergy sex abuse scandal.
5. Mass shooting in Pittsburgh synagogue raises new fears of anti-Semitism in the United States.
6. U.S. Supreme Court protects the speech rights of pro-life pregnancy centers, finding California's FACT Act unconstitutional.
7. Canada and Ireland repeal blasphemy laws, while blasphemy cases elsewhere (Pakistan, Spain, Austria, India) continue to attract attention.
8. Federal district court holds federal Female Genital Mutilation statute unconstitutional.
9. Free speech challenges to state laws designed to combat individual participation in boycott of Israel meet success.
10. Congress takes action to fight genocide; passes Elie Wiesel Genocide and Atrocities Prevention Act and.  Iraq and Syria Genocide Relief and Accountability Act .

Don Byrd at Blog From the Capital has a different set of the Top Ten.

Top Church-State and Religious Liberty Developments of 2017

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year-- including developments internationally in the mix.  Usually I select the top ten, but this year I have expanded it to 11. The selection obviously involves a good deal of subjective judgment, and I welcome e-mail comment from those who disagree with my choices.  So here are my Top Eleven picks for the rather chaotic year that is currently coming to an end:

1.  President Trump issues and reissues restrictions on immigration and entry of refugees which are challenged in the courts as "Muslim bans."

2. Supreme Court's Trinity Lutheran Church decision opens the possibility of expanded governmental aid to religious institutions.

3. Christian Evangelicals remain core supporters of Donald Trump.

4. Trump Administration expands religious and moral exemptions from ACA contraceptive coverage mandate; court challenges filed.

5. The Masterpiece Cakeshop case attracts over 90 amicus briefs as it is argued before the Supreme Court.  The Christian baker's refusal to create a wedding cake for a same-sex couple becomes a symbol of the cultural clash between ideals of religious freedom and equality, even though arguments focus on free speech issues.

6. Congress fails to repeal the Johnson Amendment, despite promises by President Trump.

7. Transgender discrimination and transgender service in the military remain high profile religious and cultural issues in the courts and in the political arena.

8. The Alt-Right march in Charlottesville reveals resurgence of traditional forms of  anti-Semitism.

9. Supreme Court's decision in Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton saves retirement plans of religiously affiliated health care networks from unanticipated and costly ERISA coverage.

10. In Israel, government's suspension of an agreement with Judaism's Reform and Conservative movements to construct a separate prayer space at the Western Wall for egalitarian prayer opens a rift with a large segment of the American Jewish community.

11. India's Supreme Court invalidates Triple Talaq marriage for Muslims in India.

For top picks by other observers of the legal and religious scene, see Don Byrd's Top Ten Religious Liberty Stories, and  Religion News Association's Top 10 Religion Stories of the Year Poll.

Top Ten Religious Liberty and Church-State Developments of 2016

Each year in December, I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year.  This was a busy year, and a number of the important developments amounted to themes that spanned many months.  So here are my Top Ten picks for the rather chaotic year that is currently coming to an end. I welcome e-mail comment from those who disagree with my choices.

1. The unexpected death of Justice Scalia leaves the Supreme Court split on important issues, including the challenges to the Obamacare contraceptive coverage mandate.

2. Religion plays unusual roles in the Presidential election contest.  Donald Trump raises issues of Muslim immigration, repeal of the Johnson amendment, draws support from Evangelicals despite a personal history that might raise questions with religious conservatives, and receives support from the alt-Right which includes anti-Semitic elements.  Hillary Clinton who has deep personal religious roots does not emphasize these in her campaign.

3. Transgender rights-- particularly access to bathrooms-- become a religious as well as political issue as the Obama administration asserts that existing anti-discrimination provisions in federal law cover discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity.

4. Supreme Court grants review in ERISA "church plan" exemption cases.  Billions of dollars in potential underfunding of retirement plans by religiously-affiliated health care systems around the country are at issue.

5. Fallout from the legalization of same-sex marriage continues as various wedding service providers assert the right to refuse to serve same-sex couples, Mississippi's Conscience Protection Act is struck down, and Alabama Chief Justice Roy Moore appeals his suspension growing of his resistance to accepting the Supreme Court's marriage equality ruling.

6. Latin crosses as part of veterans' memorials, in parks, and on county seals and the like become the latest focus of the battle over religious displays on public property.

7. State "Blaine Amendments" again become the focus of attention as the Supreme Court grants review in the Trinity Lutheran Church case and Oklahoma voters defeat a proposal to eliminate Blaine Amendments from the state constitution.

8. Federal and state RFRA's continue to be asserted, often but not always unsuccessfully, in unusual contexts-- e.g. challenging "In God We Trust" on currency, as a defense to tax evasion charges, as a defense to food stamp fraud, in connection with bankruptcy discharges, and in treatment of transgender employees.

9. Congress expands the U.S. role in protecting international religious freedom by passing the Frank R. Wolf International Religious Freedom Act.

10.  Justice Department sues cities under Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act for placing zoning impediments in the way of mosque construction.

For an alternative view of the Top Ten Religious Liberty Stories of 2016, see this post by Baptist Joint Committee blogger Don Byrd.

Top Ten Religious Liberty and Church-State Developments of 2015

Each year in December I attempt to pick the most important church-state and religious liberty developments of the past year.  This year was rich with possibilities, and some of my picks actually arose in a broader context but have will have an important impact on religious liberty claims or church-state challenges.  So here are my Top Ten picks.  I welcome readers' comments since I am sure that not everyone will agree with all the choices.

1. In Obergefell v. Hodges, the U.S. Supreme Court holds that the Constitution requires marriage equality, striking down state laws that bar same-sex marriages.
   
   
2. The battle continues over the adequacy of the Obama administration's accommodation for religious non-profits that object to the Affordable Care Act contraceptive coverage mandate. The U.S. Supreme Court will decide the issue this term after granting certiorari in seven cases.
   
   
3. Some states expand RFRA laws to protect objectors to same-sex marriage. Indiana's law provokes particular controversy forcing the legislature to backtrack. Meanwhile around the country some Christian-owned businesses continue to refuse to provide services they see as furthering same sex marriage or LGBT rights, while Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis garners national attention for her refusal to issue same-sex marriage licenses.
   
   
4. The U.S. Supreme Court becomes active on prisoners' rights issues, including claims for religious accommodation by inmates.  The Supreme Court gives RLUIPA a broad interpretation in Holt v. Hobbs.  It also interprets the "three strikes" provision that limits indigent prisoner litigation; hears oral arguments in a case on maximum fee payments by indigent prisoners litigating multiple cases; and grants certiorari on a question of exhausting administrative remedies before suing.
   
   
5. The rise of ISIL creates questions about the proper label to apply to the struggle against jihadists.  The dispute centers over the use of terminology such as "the war against radical Islam" that could be misinterpreted to suggest the U.S. is broadly at war with all Muslims.
   
   
6. The Supreme Court interprets the elements of Title VII employment discrimination claims (including claims for accommodation of religious practices) in Abercrombie & Fitch (employer motives) and Mach Mining (EEOC conciliation requirement).
   
   
7. The expression of virulent anti-Muslim sentiment raises free speech and anti-discrimination issues in cases involving anti-Muslim bus ads and a business seeking to create a "Muslim free zone."
   
   
8. The EEOC rules that discrimination on basis of sexual orientation is barred by the "sex discrimination" ban in Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.
   
   
9. The Supreme Court holds that specialty license plates  are government speech, thus impacting the many cases on license plates with religious themes or symbols.
   
   
10. The successful referendum to overturn Houston's Equal Rights Ordinance positions the battle over transgender rights as next struggle between conservative religious groups and civil rights advocates.

Top Dozen Church-State and Religious Liberty Developments In 2014

Each year in December, I attempt to highlight the most important  Church-State and Religious Liberty Developments of the past year.  Usually I identify the top ten stories.  This year however was so full of important developments that I have had to increase my nominations to the Top Dozen.  As always, I invite reader feedback on my selections and omissions.  Here they are:

1. The Supreme Court's Hobby Lobby decision allowed closely-held corporations to assert religious exercise rights of their owners.

2.  In the wake of the Supreme Court's Windsor decision, lower courts strike down same-sex marriage barriers in an increasing number of states.  The 6th Circuit is the main dissenter.

3.  Religiously-affiliated schools, hospitals and charities continue to object that administrative accommodations to the Affordable Care Act contraceptive coverage mandate are insufficient to protect their religious liberty rights.  Dozens of cases are in litigation over the issue.

4. In Town of Greece case, Supreme Court upholds non-coercive sectarian invocations at city council meetings.

5. The increasing strength of ISIS in Syria, Iraq and elsewhere threatens religious minorities in the Middle East and revives dream of a Caliphate.

6.  State RFRA proposals become more controversial as they clash with LGBT rights.

7.  Challenges to Internal Revenue Code parsonage allowance and church filing exemptions survive constitutional attack for plaintiffs' lack of standing.

8.  Satanic Temple becomes player in battle to diversify religious displays on public property, participate in literature distribution in schools and assert other religious rights.

9.  Courts continue to uphold New Jersey and California bans on sexual orientation change therapy for minors.

10. 6th Circuit requires strict causation to prove religiously motivated hate crimes against Amish.

11. Series of cases challenging definition of "church plan" under ERISA threatens legality of several Catholic hospital pension plans.

12. NLRB decision announces new test for asserting jurisdiction over unionization efforts at religiously-affiliated colleges and universities.

Earlier this month Religion Newswriters Association released their list of the Top 10 Religion Stories in 2014. (They too selected 12 stories, finding ties in two instances.) UPDATE: Also see the year's top picks from Don Byrd at Blog From the Capital.

Top 10 Church-State and Religious Liberty Developments in 2013

As the new year approaches, here is my annual attempt at picking the most important developments of the past year.  My nominations for the 2013 Top Ten Church-State and Religious Liberty Developments are:

1. The U.S. Supreme Court in United States v. Windsor strikes down Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act in an opinion by Justice Kennedy that triggers judicial and legislative expansion of marriage equality to a total of 18 states and the District of Columbia by the end of 2013.

2.  Judicial challenges by Catholic- and conservative Christian-owned small businesses to the Affordable Care Act contraceptive coverage mandate generate an intense legal debate over whether corporations have religious exercise rights.  The U.S. Supreme Court grants certiorari in two cases raising the issue.

3. A decision by the New Mexico Supreme Court in Elane Photography requires a commercial photography business to serve same-sex couples on the same basis as opposite-sex couple, despite the photographer's religious objections to same-sex marriage. A preliminary Colorado administrative decision takes the same approach on wedding cakes. In a related development, Britain's Supreme Court holds that its anti-discrimination laws require Christian hotel owners to rent rooms to same-sex couples. 

4. U.S. Supreme Court hears oral arguments in Town of Greece case.  The Court will decide on the constitutionality of opening city council meetings with sectarian prayers.

5. Numerous challenges by religiously-affiliated colleges and social service agencies to a compromise that was intended to accommodate their objections to the Affordable Care Act contraceptive coverage mandate raise the issue of how to define a "substantial burden" on religious exercise under RFRA. Courts have reached differing conclusions.

6. European Court of Human Rights decides four cases from Britain on religious accommodation of Christian employee' religious beliefs. Decisions call for a case-by-case balancing approach.

7. Egypt continues to struggle with the future role of the Muslim Brotherhood (which the government now brands a "terrorist" group) and with what its constitution should say about the role of religion.

8. Federal district court strikes down most of Utah's anti-polygamy law.

9. A variety of recent cases and legislative initiatives in the U.S. and elsewhere raise the question of what qualifies as a "religion"-- Scientology, yoga, Humanism, Naturism.

10. Federal district court holds Internal Revenue Code parsonage allowance provisions violate Establishment Clause.

 I welcome reader comments taking issue with my choices. You may be interested in the somewhat different picks by the Religion Newswriters Association for its 2013 Top 10 Religion News Stories.