In Watkinson v. Alaska Department of Corrections, (9th Cir., May 2, 2022), the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals held that Alaska did not violate the rights of a prisoner who was a practitioner of Asatru when it prevented him from using firewood purchased through the Prison Welfare Fund (PWF) for religious purposes, and when it did not allow use of the Prison Welfare Fund for inmates to pool funds to purchase juice and honey in bulk. The court said in part:
RLUIPA does not require a state to facilitate or subsidize the exercise of religion or pay for devotional accessories.... ADOC policies do not deny Plaintiff access to any item necessary for his religious ceremonies, and Plaintiff may procure all necessary items without access to the PWF. Defendants’ policies thus did not substantially burden the exercise of Plaintiff’s religious practice...
The court also rejected plaintiff's 1st Amendment claim. In addition it rejected his Equal Protection claim, even though prison authorities allowed a Native American cultural group to use PWF-purchased firewood at the prison sweat lodge. According to the court:
The prison director testified that the groups are not similarly situated because the sweat lodge is a cultural rather than a religious activity.
