Chinese Police Detain Prominent Pastor and Some Members of Unregistered Church

The New York Times reported earlier this week that on Sunday Chinese police detained Wang Yi, one of China's most prominent Protestant pastors.  His Early Rain Covenant Church, with its over 500 members, is one of many churches that are not registered with the government. These independent Protestant churches that have not complied with the registration laws are one of the fastest growing religious movements in China, claiming some 30 million adherents. More than 100 members of Early Rain were also detained, though a number were released by Monday with some of those then being placed under house arrest.

Hasidic Jews Sue Town Over Zoning Barriers

Suit was filed this week in a New York federal district court against the village of Airmont for its actions in attempting to prevent expansion of its Hasidic Jewish community.  The complaint (full text) in Congregation of Ridnik v. Village of Airmont, (SD NY, filed 12/10/2018), alleges in part:

For Hasidic Jews living in Airmont, seeking the Village’s approval for religious gatherings places applicants in a process reminiscent of the curse of Tantalus. At great expense, applicants prepare elaborate plans in order to obtain approval, which the Village uniformly declines to provide. Instead, the Village dangles promises that the applications will be approved in the future if certain modifications are made, only to then yank any hope of approval away even after the applicants make the requested modifications. Instead of providing an approval or denial, the Village requires applicants to satisfy new conditions, often citing purported problems with the applicants’ plans on which Airmont officials had already signed-off.

Injunction Denied Against Picketing Ordinance

In O'Connell v. City of New Bern, North Carolina, (ED NC, Dec. 10, 2018), a North Carolina federal district court refused to grant a preliminary injunction to block enforcement of the city's ordinance that regulates picketing.  Plaintiff wanted to share his religious, social and political message near MumFest, but was prevented from handing out literature and carrying a cross.

$4M Award Against Jehovah's Witnesses Upheld

In J.W. v, Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc., (CA App,, Dec. 10, 2018), a California state appellate court upheld an award of over $4 million to a girl who, when she was ten years old, was sexually abused by an elder of the Jehovah's Witness church.  The church was charged, among other things, with negligent supervision and failure to warn. The award came after a court struck defendant's answer as a sanction for failing to comply with discovery orders.

Supreme Court Denies Review In Attempted Cutoff of Medicaid Funds To Planned Parenthood

Over the dissent of Justices Thomas, Alito and Gorsuch, the U.S. Supreme Court today denied certiorari in Gee v. Planned Parenthood of Gulf Coast, Inc., (cert. denied, 12/10/2018). (Order list with dissenting opinion by Thomas, J.)  In the case, the 5th Circuit in a 2-1 decision (full text) upheld the district court's preliminary injunction against the state of Louisiana's termination of Medicaid contracts with Planned Parenthood. At issue in the case is whether Medicaid recipients have a private right of action to challenge the state's action, (SCOTUSblog case page).

Recent Articles of Interest

From SSRN:

• Giovanni Zaccaroni, Non-discrimination on the Ground of Religion: A Fundamental Element of the EU Constitutional Legal Order?, (University of Milano-Bicocca School of Law Research Paper No. 18-01 (2018).).
• M. C. Mirow, Léon Duguit and the Social Function of Property in Argentina , (In Paul Babie and Jessica Viven-Wilksch, eds., Léon Duguit and the Social Obligation Norm of Property: A Translation and Global Exploration. Cham: Springer, Forthcoming).
• Damir Banović & Ehlimana Memišević, Law and Religion in Bosnia and Herzegovina (December 7, 2018).
• Philippe Lord,  The Eternal Commitment: Scientology's Billion-Year Contract, (December 7, 2018).
• William P., Marshall, Third-Party Burdens and Conscientious Objection to War,(2018), (Kentucky Law Journal, Vol. 106, 2019).
• Piotr Godzisz, The Europeanization of Anti-LGBT Hate Crime Laws in the Western Balkans, (Crime, Law and Social Change, Forthcoming).
• David Adam Friedman, Bringing Candor to Charitable Solicitations, (Maryland Law Review, Forthcoming).
• Raff Donelson & Ivar Hannikainen, Fuller and the Folk: The Inner Morality of Law Revisited, (Oxford Studies in Experimental Philosophy, Volume 3. Oxford: UK, Oxford University Press, Forthcoming).

Today Is 70th Anniversary of Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Today is the 70th Anniversary of the United Nations adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 18 of the Declaration guarantees religious freedom:

Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance.

Recent Prisoner Free Exercise Cases

In Roberts v. Perry, 2018 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 204091 (WD NC, Dec. 3, 2018), a North Carolina federal district court allowed an inmate to proceed on his claims that he was denied access to the courts as to his White Supremacist security risk group designation and confiscation of his religious publications without due process.

In Richardson v. Gleason, 2018 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 205417 (ND NY, Dec. 4, 2018), a New York federal district court ordered dismissal, unless an amended complaint is filed, of a Jewish inmate's complaint that defendants failed to provide Kosher food, religious services, or religious material.

In Yah'Torah v. Hicks, 2018 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 205798 (D NJ, Dec. 4, 2018), a New Jersey federal district court allowed a Jewish inmatge to move ahead with his complaint that he was denied the regular use of fragrant oils for prayer.

Leading Hasidic Rabbi Defies New York Regulations On Yeshiva Curriculum

As previously reported, last month the New York State Education Department issued new guidelines for review of the curriculum of non-public religious and independent schools, under statutory provisions that primarily impact Hasidic Jewish yeshivas. The Forward reported last week that a leading Hasidic rabbi, Satmar Rebbe Aron Teitelbaum, is defying the New York City and New York State Education Departments, telling his followers in a speech:

We will not comply and we will not follow the state education commissioner under any circumstances. These are our words for the state education commissioner.

Religious Adoption Agency Sues Over Nondiscriminaton Rule

A suit was filed this week in New York federal district court challenging a New York regulation that (Title 18 NYCCR Sec.421.3) that adoption agencies may not discriminate against applicants for adoption services on various grounds, including sexual orientation, gender identity and marital status.  New Hope Family Services, a faith based adoption agency, refuses to recommend or place children with unmarried couples or same-sex couples.  The complaint (full text) in New Hope Family Services, Inc. v. Poole, (ND NY, filed 12/6/2018) contends that this regulation violates the agency's free exercise, free expression and equal protection rights. ADF issued a press release announcing the filing of the lawsuit.

Suit Charges Mormon Church With Dominating Utah In Change To Marijuana Initiative

A lawsuit was filed Wednesday in a Utah state trial court challenging the Utah legislature's enactment of H.B. 3001 which weakens a medical marijuana initiative passed by Utah voters last month. According to an AP report, the new law, among other things, bans a number of marijuana edibles; bars people from growing their own marijuana if they live far from a dispensary; and narrows the list of eligible medical conditions for which the drug can be used. The original Initiative was opposed by the Mormon Church, and H.B.. 3001 reflects a compromise designed to prevent the legislature from completely repealing the Initiative measure. The complaint (full text) in Epilepsy Association of Utah v. Herbert, (UT Dist. Ct., filed 12/5/2018), alleges in part:

This is an action for declaratory and injunctive relief arising from, first, the unconstitutional violation by the Utah Legislature of the constitutional right of the People to directly pass legislation through the initiative process under Article VI, Section 1 of the Utah Constitution and, second, the unconstitutional domination of the State, and interference with the State’s functions, by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (“the Church”), in violation of Article I, Section 4 of the Utah Constitution.

Art. I, Sec. 4 of the state constitution provides: "There shall be no union
of Church and State, nor shall any church dominate the State or interfere with its functions."

Christian Activist Charged After Video Of Book Burning

KCRG TV9 News reports that an Orange City, Iowa Christian activist has been charged with misdemeanor 5th Degree Criminal Mischief after making a Facebook Live video of himself burning four children's books checked out of the Orange City Public Library.  The video, made on the first day of the city's gay pride festival, showed him burning books titled "Two Boys Kissing," "This day in June," "Morris Micklewhite and the tangerine dress," and "Families, families, families."

Canada's Youth Job Program Changes Attestation Requirement After Objections By Pro-Life Groups

Global News reports that this year the Canada Summer Jobs program is changing its grant application process after objections last year from religious organizations to the requirement that they attest, in applying for funds, that "both the job and the organization’s core mandate respect individual human rights in Canada, including the values underlying the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms as well as other rights."  The rights covered included reproductive rights and non-discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. Anti-abortion groups sued arguing that the required attestation violated their freedom of expression and religious freedom. (See prior posting.) This year, no attestation is required. Instead the burden is on Service Canada to determine whether grant funds will be used to hire young people for work that will restrict reproductive right or promote prejudice or discrimination.

City Recreation Department Trip To Biblical Museums Cancelled After Objections

Christian Post reports that the Charleston, Illinois parks and recreation department has cancelled a planned town trip to southern Ohio and northern Kentucky that included visits to the Answers in Genesis Creation Museum and Ark Encounter. Freedom From Religion Foundation had complained to the city (full text of letter) that promotion of visits to these museums violates the Establishment Clause because it endorses the religious mission of museum founder Ken Ham.

EU Encourages Member States To Increase Fight Against Antisemitism

As reported by JTA, the Council of the European Union yesterday adopted a Council Declaration on the fight against antisemitism and the development of a common security approach to better protect Jewish communities and institutions in Europe (full text). Described by the European Jewish Congress as "unprecedented," the Declaration sets out eight steps that member states are encouraged to take, including increasing their security efforts for Jewish communities, institutions and citizens. Among the other suggested steps are:

implement[ing] a holistic strategy to prevent and fight all forms of antisemitism as part of their strategies on preventing racism, xenophobia, radicalisation and violent extremism....

endors[ing] the non-legally binding working definition of antisemitism employed by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) as a useful guidance tool in education and training, including for law enforcement authorities in their efforts to identify and investigate antisemitic attacks....

Santa Fe Archdiocese Files Under Chapter 11

In a letter from Archbishop John Wester (full text) dated Nov. 29, the Catholic Archdiocese of Santa Fe (NM) announced that it is filing for Chapter 11 Reorganization order the federal Bankruptcy Code in order to deal with the growing number of clergy sexual abuse claims.  The letter says in part:

Given our desire to care for all victim survivors, and given the fact that we have settled over 300 claims, but that such claims continue to be filed, I see this as the wisest and most prudent course to take. It is very important that everyone understand that we have not taken this step to avoid responsibility. On the contrary, we firmly believe that Chapter 11 is the most merciful and equitable way for the Archdiocese to address its responsibility to the victim survivors, to continue to meet its commitment to prevent abuse, and to continue its mission to all those who depend on the outreach of the Church. 

The cost of settlement of the over 300 cases which included insurance funds totaled approximately $52 million dollars of which the Archdiocese paid a substantial amount. Currently we have approximately 40 pending cases, which we need to address in a caring and Christ-like manner.

AP has additional background.

Studies Conclude Atrocities Against Rohingya Constitute Genocide

On Monday, the Public International Law and Policy Group, a global pro bono law firm, issued a 105-page report (full text) titled Documenting Atrocity Crimes Committed Against the Rohingya In Myanmar's Rakhine State. Here is an exceprt:

In March and April 2018, the Public International Law & Policy Group (PILPG), undertook an as yet unprecedented large-scale and comprehensive human rights documentation investigation mission in the refugee camps and settlement areas in Eastern Bangladesh. The purpose of this investigation mission was to provide an accurate accounting of the patterns of abuse and atrocity crimes perpetrated against the Rohingya in Myanmar’s Rakhine State and to help inform the policy decisions related to accountability in Myanmar....

Following its investigation mission, and with substantial support from an array of international attorneys and international criminal law experts, PILPG conducted a comprehensive legal analysis of the investigation’s factual findings....

The investigation mission documented a range of crimes amounting to crimes against humanity, including the particularly prevalent crimes of extermination, murder, rape and other forms of sexual violence, enslavement, forcible transfer, and persecution.... 

With regard to the crime of genocide, this Report concludes that there are reasonable grounds to believe that genocide was committed against the Rohingya in Myanmar’s northern Rakhine State....

Finally, this Report concludes that there are reasonable grounds to believe that war crimes were committed in relation to abuses and violence committed against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State.....

The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum, citing other studies, also issued a statement (full text) reaching a similar conclusion. Politico reports that the U.S. House of Representatives is expected to pass H. Res. 1091 expressing the sense of the House that genocide and crimes against humanity have been committed.

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Says Names of 11 Priests Should Be Redacted From Grand Jury Report

In In re: Fortieth Statewide Investigating Grand Jury, (PA Sup. Ct., Dec. 3, 2018), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in a 6-1 decision held that because of insufficient due process protections, the names of 11 priests petitioning the court should be redacted permanently from the publicly released grand jury report on sexual misconduct by Catholic clergy. The majority said in part:

... [T]he supervising judge’s limited review and approval of a grand jury report for public release gives it an imprimatur of official government sanction which carries great weight in the eyes of the public, and, thus, may compound the harm to a person’s reputation who is wrongly named therein. As such, we ordered the temporary redaction of Report 1 while we addressed the challenges to it. In the absence of any other viable remedy, we are compelled to find that these  redactions, with respect to Petitioners, must be made permanent.

We acknowledge that this outcome may be unsatisfying to the public and to the victims of the abuse detailed in the report. While we understand and empathize with these perspectives, constitutional rights are of the highest order, and even alleged sexual abusers, or those abetting them, are guaranteed by our Commonwealth’s Constitution the right of due process. It is the unfortunate reality that the Investigating Grand Jury Act fails to secure this right, creating a substantial risk that Petitioners’ reputations will be irreparably and illegitimately impugned....

Justice Baer filed a concurring opinion. Justice Dougherty also filed a concurring opinion, setting out procedures which he believes would provide adequate due process. Chief Justice Saylor dissented (full text), arguing that petitioners should be provided hearings (and an opportunity to testify, if they did not do so before the grand jury) before a judicial officer at which they are "provided the opportunity to advocate that the grand jury’s particularized findings of criminal and/or morally reprehensible conduct are not supported by a preponderance of the evidence." Philadelphia Tribune reports on the decision.

California City Settles Officer's Religious Discrimination Suit Against Police Chief For $2.3M

AP reports that last Friday the city of Beverly Hills, California agreed to pay $2.3 million to settle a religious discrimination lawsuit brought against it by Police Capt. Mark Rosen.  Rosen, who is Jewish, contends that Police Chief Sandra Spagnoli, through restructuring of the command staff, denied him opportunities for promotion because of his religion.  At least 20 other complaints of discrimination of various sorts have been filed against Chief Spagnoli since 2016. Rosen retired immediately after the suit was settled.

Religious Leaders Write On Religious Freedom Prospects Ahead

Deseret News on Monday posted an article titled What's next for religious freedom in 2019? Faith leaders and policymakers weigh in. The article features short essays from seven religious leaders of different faiths.